Pizza Pie Cafe in Ammon

A really good place to gI when you are really hungry. Love their salad bar!

Good salad bar. Good pizza toppings. Good pasta. Just one suggestion, make your crust softer. I don't know if it is because it sits on the buffet a while....but it can be too hard and chewy.

Food is great, my only hold off for not giving five stars is the seating. It’s really not great at all for large groups and every time we go to Pizza Pie Cafe, it’s with a ton of people. It’s very uncomfortable having to sit across from your friends and not be able to face them. The seating needs to be redesigned a little to make it more streamlined.

We have eaten at Cici, which is very similar in concept. However, Pizza Pie blows that establishment out of the water with simple quality and customer service. There were a number of restrictions due to COVID, so the tables weren't bussed and we had to switch out plates after every use. Other than that, this was truly an excellent experience. Great decor -- some Americana mixed with more modern twist. Music options were very upbeat and generationally mixed. I would recommend eating here. For the price, you're getting a quality meal and experience. Plus - they offer veteran discounts on the veteran's meal.

Throw your spicy sausage sauce in the trash. Way too much sugar in it. The server compared it to the Alfredo sauce, far from it! Pizza and service were excellent though.

The food was great with lots of variety of pizzas, pastas, and salads (incl. GF and WFPB). They have taken good precautions for covid19 like hand sanitizer placed throughout and wax paper to handle commonly used utensils in the buffet.

Several granddaughters were in town and Pizza Pie Cafe was on their bucket list. Friday night was not the best night to bring them in. There must have been a half dozen little league baseball teams and their families in there, plus the other half of Idaho Falls that doesn't play baseball. Nevertheless, the food was good, the salad and pasta bars were kept well stocked, and the pizza kept coming (although the line to get it never seemed to get smaller). There was about 15 people ahead of us in line when we got there at 6:45 and the line was just as long when we left an hour later.

Super yummy! Good service and adequate health precautions for the covid virus.

We took our kids here because our oldest is a pizza hound so we thought we would check it out. First off this place is busy so don't just plan on a quick in and out meal. They have everything from a fresh salad bar, build your own pasta bar and large assortment of all you can eat pizza slices. Overall I felt the price and quality were a fair value and with the different assortment of foods there's something for everyone. Our family will definitely be back in the near future.

This is one of our favorite places to eat as a family. We love the variety.... there's an all-you-can-eat salad, pasta, and pizza bar (including very delicious dessert pizza). We have teenage boys so this is a GREAT place where they always get full. It's such a great value as well, and they have a rewards program, which is something I look for.

Great food with plenty of space for safety great to get out again and enjoy good pizza.

Not a bad place. Food isn’t something I’d rave about! It is all you can’t eat so can’t complain there! Staff isn’t too bad one or two that seem as though they don’t care whether they need there job or not! Price is decent! Overall just pizza, pasta and salad not too mind blowing almost like a school cafeteria just in disguise.

Good food in our opinion, decent prices for a buffet, and good selection if you like 🍕 and pasta. I love the desert pizza's. My wife likes the salad bar too.